Several months ago, I received a coupon for Hello Fresh. In case you’ve been living under a rock, Hello Fresh is a service that delivers fresh ingredients, perfectly portioned to fit specific, health-conscious recipes right to your door step. There are several companies that do this – Hello Fresh, Blue Apron, Plated, Home Chef, etc. As a busy, working mom to 2-year old twins, finding the time to cook healthful, balanced meals with fresh ingredients and without breaking the bank, hasn’t been easy. Needless to say, my interest was peaked…especially since the coupon I received made my first box $29 (3 meals/2 servings).
I became obsessed. For the first time in a very long time, I was cooking at home, and my husband and children were actually eating the food. Like a true addict, I needed more. I signed up for Blue Apron and Plated, and alternated my weeks on which service I would receive. I tried to sign up for Home Chef because I’d heard good things, but they don’t deliver to my area, unfortunately. I’ve now tried multiple meals from each, and here’s how they compare.
We live on a budget, so price was a real concern. However, truth be told – we saved money…at first. We’d fallen in a bad habit of buying groceries, feeling too exhausted to cook, and eating fast food instead. Grocery bill + fast food x 5 nights/week = not cheap! I digress. Here’s how the meals stacked up:
Hello Fresh – I signed up for the Classic plan which was $69 for 3 meals @ 2 servings (approx. $11.50/serving). There’s also a family plan that comes out to about $9.99/serving.
Blue Apron – I signed up for the standard meal plan which was $59.94 for 3 meals @ 2 servings (approx. $9.99/serving). They also offer a family plan which is comparable in price.
Plated – The plan I signed up for was $48 + $6 shipping for 2 meals @ 2 servings (approx. $13.50/serving).
All three services were actually enough to feed me, my husband, and my two-year old twins. The serving sizes were pretty large so I gave my husband one, full serving, I took 1/2 serving, and my girls each took 1/4. We all had plenty. That said, the prices don’t seem as daunting when you consider that one serving easily feeds more than one (unless you have a very hungry teenager in your house – that might not work). Price winner – Blue Apron.
I have a very developed palate, and I love trying new foods. There are very few foods that I don’t like. My husband, however, is a steak & potatoes kind of guy. He will [hesitantly] try new foods, but he likes classic American food. My twins are very picky eaters. That in mind, I tried to pick meals that would satisfy all of our preferences.
Hello Fresh – I loved the meal selection with Hello Fresh. The variety was wide enough that I could satisfy my family’s cravings, and my own. Here are a few of the meals I chose: Maple Balsamic Chicken with Sweet Potatoes and Broccoli, Hearty Steak and Potatoes with Balsamic-Cranberry Pan Sauce, and Thai Pork Stir-Fry with Mint and Ginger. There were enough options to satisfy different taste-preferences, even with only 6 choices.
Blue Apron – I wasn’t very thrilled with Blue Apron’s meal selection. First of all, it took several weeks to find 3 recipes that I liked and thought my family might be willing to try. Then, I would select one meal, and others would be removed as an option. I guess this is how they keep cost down? It was very difficult to find 3 recipes that sounded good, and that Blue Apron would allow me to select together. Blue Apron also had 6 meals to choose from each week (if it would allow you to choose the 3 you wanted). Here are some of the meals I tried: Cheddar Cheeseburgers with Sauteed Onion & Romaine Salad, Spiced Chicken Chili with Chickpeas & Currants, Baked Ricotta Cannelloni with Romaine Salad & Meyer Lemon Dressing. Blue Apron does have the option of adding on wine to compliment your meal selections. I didn’t opt to try this.
Plated – By far, Plated has the best meal selection IMO. There are typically 10-11 different meals to choose from, including everything from steak and potatoes to Thai Fish Curry. I actually had a hard time narrowing it down to only 2. I wanted at least half of them. Here are some that I tried: Creamy Spinach & Artichoke Pasta, Crunchy Chicken Milanese with Honey Mustard & Arugula, and Cuban Chicken Empanadas with Lime Crema and Avocado. Plated also gives you the option of adding on desserts for a little extra money. I tried one of the dessert recipes and it’s one I’ll make repeatedly.
No doubt, the Meal Selection winner is Plated. Hello Fresh was a close second, but it just doesn’t compare to the multiple options Plated offered, and the variety.
Ease of Use
One of my main motivations to try these services was to save time on grocery shopping, and cooking. All services saved me a lot of time. However, some stood out more than others.
Hello Fresh – For me, the ease starts in the packaging. With Hello Fresh, each recipe is in its own individual box with every ingredient necessary (meat was separated, of course). Each night, I’d decide what I wanted to cook, I’d grab the box out the fridge, and I’d get started. There was no searching for this, that or that other. It may not sound like much, but it saved me a ton of time! It also didn’t take up too much room in the fridge – it was compact. The instructions were very easy to follow, and included pictures for some of the more difficult or not-so-common tasks. Each recipe had an estimated difficulty level and time expectation which I felt was very accurate. Most of the recipes took approximately 30 minutes to cook. It was SO easy!
Blue Apron – Again, Blue Apron didn’t impress me here. The ingredients were all individually packaged so I had to separate them out by meal. I guess you could say it still saved time from not having to grocery shop, but that’s about it. As far as instructions go, they were very similar to Hello Fresh. Blue Apron was a little more descriptive in how to do things, but as an experienced home cook, this felt more like a nuisance than a time-saver. If I were a new cook, I would have greatly appreciated the instructions from Blue Apron. The recipes I tried from Blue Apron took approximately 40 minutes or less. I didn’t feel like I got the ease factor with Blue Apron. It was equivalent to finding a recipe online and cooking it (without the grocery shopping, of course).
Plated – Much like Hello Fresh, all of the ingredients are separated by meal. They’re just in a bag instead of a box. It was also very easy to find the right bag and get to cooking right away.The instructions for Plated are much like the other two, except they have a side-bar that says what’s in the box, any additional ingredients you might need, and all the tools needed. This was incredibly helpful, and gave Plated a slight edge over the other two. Hello Fresh has more recently started doing this as well. Major kudos!
The Ease of use winner is a tie – Hello Fresh & Plated.
I’m not big into recycling. I probably should be, but I’m just not. So, I’m not talking about packaging in reference to the effect on the environment – merely how it was delivered and if there were any issues from the way in which it was packaged.
Hello Fresh – The packaging was superb. Inside the box that came to my doorstep was a large insulated bag. All inserts (recipes, etc.) were outside of the bag and on top to keep them dry. Inside the bag were 3 boxes, clearly labeled – one for each meal. Underneath those boxes was a cardboard divider, an ice pack, and then all of the meat, and more ice packs. I never had anything leak, I never had any produce bruised, and my food was always cold – no matter how long it sat on my doorstep.
Blue Apron – I was not impressed with the packaging here. Inside the box that came to my doorstep were…all of the ingredients and some ice packs. Most ingredients were individually packaged in plastic so if you are environmentally conscious about these things, you wouldn’t be very happy. Also, I had an ice pack bust, and it was all over everything. It was a nightmare to clean up.
Plated – Packaging was…ok…here. Inside the box that came to my doorstep was an insulated bag. All inserts were outside of the bag, and inside were the bags, clearly labeled for each meal. The meat was also separated. My issue with the packaging was that the ingredients are not well protected inside the bag. I often had ingredients which had busted open, or were leaking. This happened on more than one occasion. I liked that everything was grouped, but I didn’t like that the bag wasn’t very protective.
The Packaging winner is easy – Hello Fresh.
This is hard to judge because taste is very subjective; however, I’m basing my rating on the opinions of my whole family, and we all have very different taste.
Hello Fresh – We were incredibly satisfied with nearly every meal we tried. There were 1-2 that didn’t pack a big punch in flavor, and we just said, “ok – wouldn’t get that one again.” There were a few that blew us away and that have become regulars in our meal planning. There were none that we outright didn’t like and couldn’t finish. Overall, my family was incredibly happy with Hello Fresh.
Blue Apron – There was only one meal from Blue Apron that I really enjoyed. There was one my family wouldn’t eat, and several that were just ok. I wasn’t overly impressed. Truly, there isn’t much to write about here.
Plated – Taste was phenomenal. My family really enjoyed most of the meals from Plated. There were none that we didn’t like. My girls ate salad, and squash, and all kinds of foods they wouldn’t normally try.
The Taste winner is Plated. Hello Fresh was really close though.
Ease of Skipping Meals/Cancelling/and Making Meal Selections
Hello Fresh – Skipping meals, making meal selections, and even deactivating my service was as easy as pushing a button. I never had any issues with choices I made, and it took little to no time at all.
Blue Apron – Way too many issues here. The website and app aren’t well-optimized so it took forever to make meal selections from my phone. I almost always had to go to my desktop computer to make selections or skip. Also, one week that I skipped, I was charged and received a box. I was out of town. I wasn’t happy to have a box of rotting food on my doorstep when I got home. Blue Apron did correct the issue, but only with credit for another box. I should have been given a refund. Also, I’m STILL trying to cancel my Blue Apron subscription. The process certainly isn’t as simple. Instead of being able to cancel myself, I have to put in a request to cancel.
Plated – Skipping meals, making selections, and deactivating my service was incredibly easy. I never had any issues, and it was always very quick.
The Ease of Skipping/Cancelling/Selecting winner is a tie between Plated and Hello Fresh. The process was very similar for both.
Overall, Blue Apron was easy to nix for me. The cost was cheaper, but it also wasn’t as easy, didn’t taste as good, and I had multiple issues with my service. Plated and Hello Fresh were very comparable for me. I don’t know that I can name a winner between the two. Plated is more expensive, but there’s more meal options and every meal was a hit. Hello Fresh was beautifully packaged, reliable, and tasted so, so good.
If you’re a busy mom looking for a little more ease in your life, I recommend giving these services a try. I definitely don’t regret it! Before you do, find a coupon code! Each of these services gives out tons of coupons and free boxes to people who have been using the service consistently. Don’t pay full price for your first box. Here are the coupons I have:
I don’t have one for Blue Apron – sorry!